The New Manager’s Guide to Employee Motivation Myths

As a manager, employee motivation is an important part of your job. You need to find a way to get the most from your employees, keeping them on task and always striving for more. Unfortunately, new managers thrown into the fire often make false assumptions about employee motivation. If that’s you, you need to know what really works to motivate your staff. Here are some of the most common misconceptions and alternative approaches that will reap better rewards.

Myth #1: Fear is a good motivator

Some organizations use the Darth Vader school of management philosophy; if you keep employees in constant fear of losing their jobs, they’ll stay hungry and on edge.

The reality: Fear is only a good motivator for a short time. Constantly worrying about their job makes stress skyrocket for most employees. Eventually, stress leads to burn out, loss of productivity and most likely, employee turnover.

Try this: Instead of threatening, try positive reinforcement. People instinctively strive for excellence when they believe managers and others notice and recognize their efforts.


Myth #2: Some people just refuse to be motivated

The old school of thought believes that some employees are just lazy and won’t respond to anything, either the carrot or the stick.

The reality: Just like everyone has his or her own hopes and desires, everyone has specific motivators. It’s your job as a manager to discover what drives each member of your staff and use that to push him or her forward.

Try this: Identify what is holding back poor performers, then find out what it will take to get them up to par. The downside of this is that sometimes an employee is just not a good fit for your organization.


Myth #3: People prefer to set their own goals

Some managers like to take a hands-off approach to their staff, allowing each employee to determine his or her own goals and how they fit in with the overall target.

The reality: While lots of employees do relish a certain amount of freedom in their work, unclear goals and benchmarks can cause unnecessary stress and lead to missed deadlines and poor quality work.

Try this: Work hand-in-hand with your employees to develop goals. Find out what their strengths and weaknesses are, then involve them in the goal-setting process.


Myth #4: You can systematically apply an employee motivation system to cover all employees

Some managers believe that one consistent motivation strategy should be sufficient to keep all employees engaged. Consistency allows everyone to know exactly what is expected and what the results of success and failure will be.

The reality: Just like everyone has a different personality, not everyone responds to the same motivators. What works for one employee is not guaranteed to work for another.

Try this: Take the time to talk to each member of your staff individually. Find out what makes him or her tick, then use this knowledge to push the right motivation buttons.


Myth #5: Money is the best motivator

In order to reward or encourage employees, some companies will simply throw more money at them, assuming this will keep morale high.

The reality: While everyone would like to have more money, more money does not necessarily equal job happiness.

Try this: While very few employees in the history of the world have turned down a pay increase, multiple studies have shown that a good work environment where employees are happy is a much better motivator than money.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.